Neighbors, opposed to a planned Haverhill bed and breakfast that would also host events, this week appealed the City Council’s approval of a special permit.
Judith Biewener and Timothy J. Sturgeon filed the zoning complaint Monday night in Land Court, charging city councilors exceeded their authority in allowing “indoor and outdoor events on the property for up to 30 guests.” The city was notified Tuesday.
Biewener and Sturgeon, both of 419 E. Broadway, said in their complaint they do not object to a standalone bed and breakfast next door at 423 E. Broadway, but will “suffer noise, disturbance, runoff and disruption” if the event business operates immediately adjacent to their home.
They name the Yamin family—Maryam, Arash, Sherwin and Nikka Yamin—and all 11 Haverhill city councilors as defendants.
City councilors granted the permit Sept. 22 requiring Salehi-Ala-Yamin to live in the house, reduce the number of guests at parties and events, refrain from erecting large event tents in the yard, keep any parties within the confines of the house, install additional screening between her properties and her neighbors and pay for the cost of additional traffic signs on East Broadway as suggested by the Haverhill Police Department.
Biewener and Sturgeon said Mariam’s Cottage first opened in April of 2025, hosting guests and then a family wedding two months later under a tent, and a sign was placed that July advertising the business. They added the business closed after neighbors filed complaints with the Haverhill building commissioner’s office.
They argue a city ordinance limits the level and type of business activity. The Yamin family filed for a special permit last March that would permit overnight lodging and breakfast as well as “weddings and similar outdoor events…afternoon teas, baby showers, engagement parties and household and handicraft classes on cooking, gardening, soap-making and flower arrangement.”
Attorney Philip H. Graeter of Beverly, representing Biewener and Sturgeon, told the Land Court the city’s bed and breakfast ordinance prohibits other business activities. Further, they argued, the day after the permit was granted the applicant began expanding the driveway and parking area “in a manner wholly inconsistent with the site plans on which the approval was based.”
Over the long term, the complaint alleges the Council’s “absence of any limits in the special permit” could mean expanded meal service merely by describing the use as an “event.”
