Haverhill city councilors Tuesday night rejected the business community’s plan to encourage a stronger commercial and industrial base by shifting a little more of the tax burden onto homeowners.
Instead, councilors maintained for a seventh year a tax rate split of 65% for commercial and industrial property and 35% for homeowners. This year, that amounts to property taxes on the average single-family home rising from $5,962 to $6,148—or $186 more a year. Commercial property taxpayers, on the other hand, will see average bills rise from $18,080 to $19,170, or $1,090 more. Jeffrey Linehan, a former Haverhill business owner who spoke for the Greater Haverhill Chamber of Commerce and Greater Haverhill Foundation, asked councilors to lower business’ share by 5%, or 60% more than residential.
“Haverhill needs businesses. More business means more jobs. Businesses pay the bills and almost have no costs to the city. They are a gift, but the tax rate for commercial property is too high so businesses in Haverhill have left and it’s difficult to find new businesses because of this high commercial tax rate,” he said.
Linehan said Haverhill ‘s commercial base has dropped from nearly 30% to just 11%—much less than area communities. What’s worse, he said, commercial property is being converted to residential, reducing the amount of available land in which to attract businesses. He added city residents have to travel 30 minutes to work every day because Haverhill doesn’t have enough local jobs.
Ward 5 Councilor Shaun P. Toohey pushed for raising commercial taxes to the maximum share to give residents a break.
“The taxpayers—the residential side—need a break in a big way. The economy has changed. It’s getting tougher and tougher, day in and day out, I hear constantly and I agree with them,” he said.
Haverhill Mayor Melinda E. Barrett told councilors a rebound in the commercial property market, however, brings residential taxes lower than officials estimated last spring.
“We thought the single-family home would be at $245 (higher on average) because commercial industrial valuations have improved, unlike the last two years. It ended up coming in for residential at $186, so there’s a win there,” she said.
No residents spoke at the meeting.
Councilors acknowledged the option of shifting commercial, industrial and personal property taxes to the maximum 75% would still bring higher taxes to pay $285.2 million in current spending that went into effect last July.
Ward 6 Councilor Michael S. McGongale led the effort, seconded by Ward 1 Councilor Ralph T. Basiliere, to maintain the status quo.
“I will make a motion Mr. President to keep the rate at 165—both balancing the needs of business, understanding that we do not want to have any businesses exit the city, while still being fair to the residents,” he said.
Council Vice President John A. Michitson, Basiliere, Ward 2 Councilor Daniel R. Diodati, at-large Councilor Thomas J. Sullivan, Ward 3 Councilor Devan M. Ferreira, Ward 4 Councilor Melissa J. Lewandowski and McGonagle voted to keep the current split, while Toohey voted against. At-large Councilor Colin F. LePage and Ward 7 Councilor Catherine P. Rogers were absent.
