Haverhill Councilors Hold Firm on School Budget; Won’t Add Money

Ward 5 City Councilor Shaun P. Toohey. (WHAV News file photograph.)

To submit school announcements, click on image.

Haverhill city councilors wrestled Monday with how to avoid cutting school programs without adding to tax bills.

At the final public hearing, Ward 3 Councilor Devan M. Ferreira, the lone vote two weeks ago in favor of more money for schools, proposed the city give the schools $350,000 more to cover cuts in programs that would immediately impact students.

“When we talk about school success rates, when we talk about literacy rates, when we talk about achievement across the board for our public school students, continuing to limit access to programs that provide this broad, diverse education that we know everyone needs, is going to keep us in a cycle of having a hard time to move our achievement gaps forward,” she argued.

Ward 1 Councilor Ralph T. Basiliere responded he cannot endorse what he referred to a “slush fund” for the school department. Ward 6 Councilor Michael S. McGonagle pointed out that even if the Council added money for the schools, only the school department can decide how to use it and there’s there is no guarantee programs would be restored. Vice President John A. Michitson said he thinks it’s too late to re-work the budget. Ward 4 Councilor Melissa J. Lewandowski agreed saying it amounts to “robbing Peter to pay Paul.”

Two weeks ago, on a motion from at large school committee member Toni A. Sapienza Donais, the Haverhill School Committee voted 7-3 to ask the city to add $1 million to its budget, an idea the City Council voted down 9-1.

Superintendent Margaret Marotta’s proposed $137 million spending plan for the year that begins July 1 represents a 2.39% increase over the current budget. The city’s contribution would be $40.6 million with the state contributing $96.4 million in Chapter 70 education aid. The school budget is a part of the overall draft city budget of $285.2 million advanced by Mayor Melinda E. Barrett. Ward 5 Councilor Shaun P. Toohey suggested that if the school department sharpened its pencils and reallocated resources, they could find $350,000 to restore programs Ferreira values.

“I think if we send a message and push back, if you will, and say, ‘Madam Superintendent slash School Committee, can you rework those numbers? Can you take another look at Circuit Breaker reimbursement? Can you look at the increase in electricity in all those areas? Can you take a look at those interventionists?” Toohey suggested.

Saying Haverhill schools have been underfunded for years, Ferreira said she doesn’t think sending a memo helps the situation because she trusts school officials have already done a comprehensive job.

In the end, councilors voted 11-0 to accept Barrett’s draft budget as is. The budget comes for a final vote Tuesday, June 16. The proposed budget, which would go into effect July 1, represents a 2.9% increase over last year’s $277.1 million, and would raise taxes by $245 for the average home valued at $561,903.

The average tax bill would increase 4.1%, slightly lower than last year’s 4.6%. Of that, $245 average residential property tax increase, employee benefits account for $90; public safety, $67; and schools, $58. She said added expenses include health insurance premiums and the city’s contribution to Whittier Regional Vocational Technical High School.

Comments are closed.